Meet Dylan Conaway. For those in Morgantown & the surrounding cities, the locals know who he is. If it were up to the incarcerated Shelia Eddy, it would be Dylan occupying her jail cell right now. (or her bunk bed in a dorm hall since she is in a juvenile detention center until she turns 18 in September)

At the beginning of 2013, after Rachel Shoaf had confessed to authorities on January 3, Shelia Eddy started planting the rumors that Dylan killed Skylar. Half of Shelia remained in her brazen reckless denial that the circulating rumors of her still free as a bird bff Rachel confessing were just lies by the haters & taunters trying to drive her crazy with guilt, while the other half of her apparently wasn’t about to take the “seeing is believing” (in Rachel remaining free) theory to heart & thus set out to destroy a young man’s life by targeting Dylan Conaway for self-preservation precautionary measures.

Dylan Conaway with killer Shelia Eddy on his lap. Below is Dylan, Shelia, Skylar, & Shania.

195980_1995642256037_7534323_n 196564_1993862411542_7825083_n 197080_1993860331490_1556298_n 206884_1993864651598_7454185_n

The rumors took on a life of it’s own & branched out in numerous directions. The town was abuzz over “DC” & his role in the murder of Skylar Neese. Shelia was probably smiling, amused with herself as she admired her work, looking at the local message boards gossiping away with things like:

Shelia Eddy created these circulating rumors about Dylan Conaway in January 2013
Shelia Eddy created these circulating rumors about Dylan Conaway in January 2013

while at the same time tweeting away with things like how no one on this earth can handle Rachel & herself & that she loves loves loves having the upper hand & blocking someone from her thoughts so they never existed.

Fast forward 5 months. Rachel Shoaf & Shelia Eddy are both in custody in juvenile detention centers, where Rachel is to be sentenced any day now & Shelia is still awaiting her first degree murder charge, either in PA or WV, as an adult so that her name is finally unleashed to the world, & Dylan Conaway has reached out to us:


His initiative to come to us as himself & not under some profanity-laced alias like we have been approached by others – is a pretty stand-up thing to do. We were suspicious that the motive was manipulation to control the situation, but he passed our tests. He is 100% innocent.

Now, in his first interview ever, Dylan answered any question I threw at him regarding Shelia Eddy, Skylar Neese, Shania Ammons & more via email, phone, & skype over a couple day span. When I anticipated his answers not being good enough for the locals of Morgantown who would be reading this first & foremost with the most critical an eye, I drilled him to elaborate. Dylan also discusses the toll that Shelia’s destruction has taken on his family, particularly his mother.

551274_4387784267045_2122778491_n 734157_4108116755532_1670256408_n

Click the emails below for the Q & A interview with Dylan Conaway!

Click the emails above for the Q & A Interview with Dylan Conaway!

Dylan reveals that he was Shelia’s “first” sexual partner, that he did not hook up with Skylar because she looked too young, & that Shelia attacked him when he would’t commit to a relationship before their falling out as she moved to Morgantown. I found Dylan to be 100% credible & sincere. Everything he said made perfect sense & there is a reason why authorities asked if he would take a polygraph & then never followed up. We did too. Dylan likes his marijuana, but there is nothing about that to make a massive skyrocketing leap to murder.

Happy 4th of July everyone & take a moment to say a prayer for Skylar, who left this earth & found true freedom from this sick world a year ago on Saturday the 6th…..

Share this story


*June 1, 2013 UPDATE* ORIGINAL STORY The Murder of Skylar Neese & her 2 BFF Killer’s Rachel Shoaf & Shelia Eddy

*June 8, 2013 UPDATE* The Globe & Dateline NBC have both contacted us with interest to also report on the Skylar Neese murder. 

*June 14, 2013 UPDATE* Police Chief of Morgantown hears about this report. The heat is on the authorities now to bring justice to Skylar & life in prison to Shelia!!!

*June 20, 2013 UPDATE* Shania Ammons goes private, while we go more public!

*June 25, 2013 UPDATE* Coroner refuses to give up the body of Skylar Neese to her parents – CALL & EMAIL HIM!

*June 25, 2013 UPDATE* Skylar Neese Murder – Details emerge about another suspect being investigated

*June 27, 2013 UPDATE* Shania Ammons Arrested, About the Gang, & Mail.

*June 29, 2013 UPDATE* Radar Online credits NewsBall for the Skylar Neese Murder story in their article

*June 30, 2013 UPDATE(VIDEO) Mass media outlets are protecting a killer – SO Shelia Eddy Shelia Eddy SHELIA EDDY SHELIA EDDY!!!!!!

*July 1, 2013 UPDATE* LANDMARK MOMENT: Examiner gives NewsBall credit & identifies Shelia Eddy

*July 9, 2013 UPDATE* (VIDEO) EXCLUSIVE Footage of Killer Shelia Eddy with victim Skylar, text convos, family pictures, & case updates

*July 19, 2013 UPDATE* (AUDIO) EXCLUSIVE – Close family member of Shelia Eddy reveals more details that the authorities won’t share

*January 24. 2014 UPDATE* UPDATE: Skylar Neese’s Killer GUILTY & SENTENCED! Defiant & brazen Shelia Eddy pleads GUILTY to killing Skylar Neese & is QUIETLY sentenced the same day!

*February 20, 2014 UPDATE* JAM PACKED FINALE on the Skylar Neese Murder Case: lesbian sex tape confirmed, Shelia’s mugshot & her prison mailing address, new pictures, interviews & more

*February 26, 2014 UPDATE* Rachel Shoaf sentenced to 30 years in prison to close the saga on Skylar Neese murder story – Dramatic Sentencing Hearing Sheds Light on Confession

*March 5, 2014 UPDATE* The Skylar Neese Epilogue – Everything from Shelia Eddy PRISON LETTERS to Skylar’s Story on NATIONAL TV SHOWS

One Response

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *